Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jesse Parent's avatar

It's a bag of mixed feelings reading this, including pt 3. "What commonly held belief in the tech community do you believe is wrong?"

I agree that the doomer v accelerationist approach is wrong, very much, and support much of what Cosmos is doing to try to bridge those gaps.

Yet the nuclear example feels a bit strange especially considering this is coming from an economic point of view.

"The same will happen if AI causes major harm—courts and voters will shut AI progress down."

Where, in Europe? The US government is doing everything possible to take the teeth out of legislation now, or for ten years ahead, or still at the state level. This is less about finger wagging at the USA, and more about the severe disparity the space is having to deal with.

"The commonly held belief that “moving fast” means cutting corners on safety is backward. In reality, security powers progress."

I would suggest a term more like *real progress*, or sustainable / enduring progress, and not imaginary, feel-good outputs, which I do think is what the heart of the message is getting at - and I approve of.

"Banks and hospitals won’t deploy agents at scale without trustworthy assurance and insurance."

Isn't this already a reality, though? It is deployed now, at scale, with the damage control machine learning teams stuffed out in hospital basements, ready to try to remedy things, after the fact. Depending on preprint or dev blogs at best, with unvetted practices are already put into place, both """to save lives""" and to make a lot of profit.

All in all, yes to risk taming and pushing the narrative in that direction.

But... there are bigger, uglier things in the way, that will need to be dealt with as well; AI as a means of capturing market spaces and exploiting wild west type spaces are not going to be interested in insurance, particularly when there little skin in the game and thereby consequences for their harvesting actions.

Yet, it is indeed good to see the means for alternatives, grounded in rigor, being forged, here. Thanks for the write up.

Kase Fenley's avatar

This is will definitely be successful

No posts

Ready for more?